Pigeon takeoff
The prompt “A pigeon taking off from a stone ledge, wings fully extended at the top of the stroke”
Wing articulation plus the moment of leaving a surface. Feet frequently melt into the stone.
- Models tested
- 16
- Top score
- 5.00 10 models tied
- Average
- 4.73
- Lowest
- 3.38 PixVerse v5.5
Every model, same prompt
The clips on screen play together from the first frame, muted. Open one for sound, controls and our notes.
Wan 3.0
AlibabaThe pigeon leaves the ledge cleanly with wings fully extended at the top of the stroke.
Vivix W1
VivixThe pigeon lifts off cleanly, feet separating from the stone, with wings fully extended at the top of the stroke.
FLUX 3
Black Forest LabsThe pigeon crouches and lifts off cleanly, feet separating from the stone, with wings fully extended at the top of the stroke.
Kling 3.0 Turbo
Kuaishou
MiniMax H3
MiniMaxCorrect crouch, wing extension and push-off from the ledge, clean separation from stone.
MiniMax Hailuo 02
MiniMaxWingbeat, neck and push-off all anatomically correct through the full takeoff sequence, verified frame by frame.
Google Veo 3.1
GoogleWingbeat, feet push-off and climb trajectory all anatomically and aerodynamically correct.
Seedance 2.5
ByteDanceWings articulate correctly and feet cleanly leave the ledge.
Seedance 2.0
ByteDanceWings articulate correctly and feet cleanly leave the ledge.
OpenAI Sora 2
OpenAIAuthentic wing articulation through thrust and glide.
Google Gemini Omni
GoogleBird actually leaves the ledge and completes a convincing flight with correct wing/tail mechanics -- unlike Runway Gen-4.5 and PixVerse 5.5, where it never took off.
Kling 4.0
KuaishouClean take-off with wings fully extended, followed by a cut at about 4 seconds to a wider shot of the bird in flight. Checked frame by frame.
Grok Video
xAICorrect wing/leg anatomy; wingbeat rate a touch slow for a real pigeon.
Kling 3.0
KuaishouSound wing/foot anatomy, minor wingtip smearing on fast flaps.
Runway Gen-4.5
RunwayWing trailing edge shows a stacked/ghosted-feather look during the fastest upstroke; verified via frames -- consistent with motion-smear artifacting rather than full anatomical breakdown.
PixVerse v5.5
PixVerseBird flaps vigorously but never actually leaves the ledge -- verified via frame extraction (final frame still shows both feet planted, wings spread but airborne motion never happens): confirmed prompt/physics failure, the requested takeoff simply doesn't occur.
Ranked by our blind vision-model judge; models with the same score share a position. Read how we test.