Crane to skyline
The prompt “Crane shot rising from street level to reveal a city skyline at golden hour”
Large vertical translation revealing new scene content that must be plausible and stable.
- Models tested
- 16
- Top score
- 5.00 10 models tied
- Average
- 4.65
- Lowest
- 2.67 MiniMax Hailuo 02
Every model, same prompt
The clips on screen play together from the first frame, muted. Open one for sound, controls and our notes.
Vivix W1
VivixSmooth vertical rise from street level that reveals a stable golden-hour skyline.
FLUX 3
Black Forest LabsSteady vertical rise from street level that reveals a stable golden-hour skyline.
PixVerse v5.5
PixVerse
Runway Gen-4.5
Runway
MiniMax H3
MiniMaxGenuine vertical rise revealing the skyline, occluded at frame 1.
Google Veo 3.1
GoogleSkyline reveal is geometrically stable, no warping buildings.
Seedance 2.5
ByteDanceReal reveal: skyline hidden at street level, revealed only as the crane rises.
Seedance 2.0
ByteDanceReal reveal: skyline is hidden at frame one and becomes visible only as the crane rises.
Grok Video
xAIReal reveal-style crane rise, stable architecture, succeeds where Sora failed on this exact prompt.
Kling 3.0
KuaishouTextbook crane reveal with stable parallax, succeeds where Sora failed on this exact prompt.
Google Gemini Omni
Google
Wan 3.0
AlibabaSmooth rise that ends on a golden-hour skyline, but it starts a few storeys above the street rather than at street level. Checked frame by frame.
Kling 4.0
KuaishouGolden-hour skyline, but the camera starts at rooftop height and mostly pushes forward instead of rising from the street. Verified frame by frame.
OpenAI Sora 2
OpenAIFAILURE MODE: skyline is fully visible from frame 1, no reveal, just a subtle drift, so the requested crane move is not really delivered despite clean geometry.
Kling 3.0 Turbo
KuaishouCuts from street level to a full aerial view in under a second instead of a continuous crane rise. Verified directly against extracted frames: street-level at ~2.25s, already fully aerial by ~3.25s, no visible gradual ascent between.
MiniMax Hailuo 02
MiniMaxFAILURE MODE: camera stays static instead of rising; skyline is stable but shown fully from frame one rather than revealed.
Ranked by our blind vision-model judge; models with the same score share a position. Read how we test.