Genativity

Sung line

The prompt “A person singing the line "hold on to me" with visible breath and sustained vowel shapes”

Sustained vowels differ from speech. Tests whether audio sync is real or approximated.

Models tested
16
Top score
5.00 10 models tied
Average
4.59
Lowest
1.17 MiniMax Hailuo 02

Every model, same prompt

The clips on screen play together from the first frame, muted. Open one for sound, controls and our notes.

Wan 3.0

Alibaba
5.00

Sung "hold on to me", confirmed in the audio, with long held vowels and visible breath.

Vivix W1

Vivix
5.00

Sung "hold on to me", confirmed in the audio, with sustained open vowels and visible breath.

FLUX 3

Black Forest Labs
5.00

Sung "hold on to me", confirmed in the audio, with sustained open vowels and visible breath.

5.00

Sings the requested lyric with mouth shapes convincingly synced to the sustained vocal notes.

MiniMax H3

MiniMax
5.00

Audio present, sustained melody matches the sung phonemes.

5.00

Sustained vowel shapes and visible breath match the sung phrase precisely.

Seedance 2.5

ByteDance
5.00

Audible singing with sustained vowel shapes.

Seedance 2.0

ByteDance
5.00

Audible singing with sustained, elongated vowel shapes distinct from normal speech.

5.00

Sung line matches, articulation tracks the melody.

5.00

Sustained vowels matched to mouth shapes, visible breath.

4.92

Kling 4.0

Kuaishou
4.83

Sings "hold on to me" twice, confirmed in the audio, with sustained vowels; the clip cuts to a close-up of the mouth and back. Checked frame by frame.

4.78

Silent clip (no native audio); expressive mouth/vowel shapes plausible for studio singing.

PixVerse v5.5

PixVerse
4.03

Mouth shapes read as breathing/exhaling into cold air rather than singing vowel shapes -- the model appears to have depicted the wrong action entirely; not independently frame-verified, moderate-severe discount given how specific and confident the description was.

Kling 3.0

Kuaishou
3.75

Mouth shapes and breath vapor present, but silent, no vocal track.

1.17

FAILURE MODE: no audio track; mouth shows generic singing-style morphs unrelated to the actual sung phrase.

Ranked by our blind vision-model judge; models with the same score share a position. Read how we test.

This page ranks by benchmark score only. See affiliate disclosure.